Fri Dec 28, 2012 7:45 am
FWIW...
A couple years ago I ran three experiments on my home brewery splitting an 8 gallon batch between a 5 gallon glass carboy and a corny keg. I was looking to see of there were inexpensive alternatives to glass fermenters, and didn't like a plastic option. The beer in the corny keg did not attenuate as well as the the beer in the carboy about 2-4 sg points. Both fermenters sat side-by-side in a temp conditioned space. I pitch a vial in each from the same date of packaging.
Obviously there are may variables, but:
- Effectiveness of aeration 'shake method' could be different between the two shapes. I was using a 2 minute swirl technique at the time.
- Temperature swings may have been more immediate in the corny as heat conducts better in metal than glass.
JZ mentioned in the Brew Strong podcast on fermenters that the narrow shape may impact convection liquid movement of the beer as it ferments.
I have since moved to fermenting in 50L olive oil fustis.
The Fool.
Non-Motorized Mechanized Division, BN Army