Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:08 pm
Maybe Petedadink or BDawg (our only two certified judge participants) can chime in here - but I was thinking about how we can make the judging process a little easier for some of the people that have never formally judged.... especially with a Specialty Category 23.
Perhaps it would be best to leave half of each bottle full during the tasting, and "double back" for a mini-BOS round to tighten up scores. Go through each entry and give it a score, then go back to each one and make sure that each of your scores really falls in line with the overall score descriptors (ie. is the beer "Outstanding", "Excellent", "Very Good", etc.). I know that flight order is a factor even with very experienced judges. I can only imagine that it will have an even greater effect with less experienced judges - unless the beers are tasted together again (a la BOS).
Thoughts?
Mylo
"Life is too short to bottle homebrew." - Me
"HEINEKEN? Fuck that shit! Pabst Blue Ribbon!!!" - Dennis Hopper, in Blue Velvet